| Total | Partidos | Victorias | Empates | Derrotas | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 312 | 110 | (35%) | 96 | (31%) | 106 | (34%) |
| Casa | 156 | 71 | (46%) | 51 | (33%) | 34 | (22%) |
| Fuera | 156 | 39 | (25%) | 45 | (29%) | 72 | (46%) |
| Item | Competición | Local | Visitante | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mayor victoria en casa | Costa Rica Verano 2015 | Cartaginés | 7-2 | Limón FC |
| Mayor victoria fuera | Liga Costa Rica Clausura 2020/21 | Guadalupe | 0-3 | Cartaginés |
| Torneo Clausura 2019 | Carmelita | 0-3 | Cartaginés | |
| Torneo Clausura 2019 | S. Miguel Guadalupe | 0-3 | Cartaginés | |
| Mayor derrota fuera | Liga Costa Rica Clausura 2022/23 | Guadalupe | 5-1 | Cartaginés |
| Liga Costa Rica Verano 2012 | Saprissa | 4-0 | Cartaginés | |
| Costa Rica Verano 2015 | Alajuelense | 6-2 | Cartaginés | |
| Mayor derrota en casa | Liga Costa Rica Clausura 2022/23 | Cartaginés | 0-5 | Alajuelense |
