| Total | Partidos | Victorias | Empates | Derrotas | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 784 | 264 | (34%) | 203 | (26%) | 317 | (40%) |
| Casa | 392 | 172 | (44%) | 105 | (27%) | 115 | (29%) |
| Fuera | 392 | 92 | (23%) | 98 | (25%) | 202 | (52%) |
| Item | Competición | Local | Visitante | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mayor victoria en casa | Division Four 1958/59 | Hartlepool United | 10-0 | Barrow AFC |
| Mayor victoria fuera | League Two 1999/00 | Carlisle United | 0-3 | Hartlepool United |
| League Two 1999/00 | Hull City | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2022/2023 | Grimsby Town | 1-4 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2006/07 | Grimsby Town | 1-4 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2016/2017 | Grimsby Town | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2006/07 | Darlington | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2015/2016 | Morecambe | 2-5 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2013/2014 | Mansfield Town | 1-4 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2013/2014 | Exeter City | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 1995/96 | Mansfield Town | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 1995/96 | Bury | 0-3 | Hartlepool United | |
| Mayor derrota fuera | League Two 1996/97 | Brighton & Hove Albion | 5-0 | Hartlepool United |
| League Two 2016/2017 | Stevenage | 6-1 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2021/2022 | Leyton Orient | 5-0 | Hartlepool United | |
| League Two 2015/2016 | Plymouth Argyle | 5-0 | Hartlepool United | |
| Mayor derrota en casa | League Two 2016/2017 | Hartlepool United | 0-5 | Cambridge United |
| League Two 2022/2023 | Hartlepool United | 0-5 | Stockport County |
